With AI getting more and more capable of creating art content every passing day, I get a lot of questions about it. Also at this years IGDC I was invited to a panel discussion titled ‘The Next Era of Game Art - Craft, Creativity and Technology’ where we discussed how this is affecting the present and where the future of this might be. Here are some thoughts I have on this matter, this also includes bits of some of the answers I gave at the panel talk since they are quite similar. As usual these are my own thoughts and do no represent my current or past employers.
- AI can touch the art content pipeline, but it should not originate what the player of my game should see - that part should always be defined by a human. Let AI remove the grind and the grunt work, the artists should define the craft and intent.
- Use AI where there is a correct answer: UVs, retopology, LODs, validation, batch processing and so on. Artists when there’s a choice to be made: art direction, colors, composition, typography, style and what to leave out. AI for tooling is fair game in my book: you don’t ship your tools, you ship your game.
- AI amplifies what you bring, it is a tool. AI is also trained on what’s available, and majority of what is available is average. If you don’t bring anything to the table, your output with AI will be average as well and won’t stand out from the masses that are doing the same.
- AI generated content doesn’t have a soul, it doesn’t have character. Humans have intent, AI is a pattern prediction system. I can want a scene to feel lonely or tense, AI can’t do that. This is what sets good artists apart: taste, strong fundamentals, explaining intent.
- As a studio your identity is your most valuable asset, don’t spend it to save time. Figure out what makes your game unique (the look, hero assets, silhouettes) and what’s fair to iterate with AI (prep work, pipelines, variations within an established art style). Use AI to get time back, and use it on what makes your work unique.
- Don’t cut off junior roles, you are cutting your future seniors. The tedious work that now AI takes over is how juniors learnt the craft. Automating them without a plan means that there won’t be any seniors left after 10 years. Teach juniors fundamentals, and have a strong mentorship and review culture.